DRep Standards Institute

0/16 fields

autosaves in this browser

Twelve checks, yes or no, ten minutes. Yes is always the safer answer, so every no is a flag.

The governance action

Identify the action so this record stands on its own later.

0/3 done

Action title

Use the title as the proposer wrote it, so this record can be matched later.

Action identifier

The on-chain identifier, if the action is already submitted. Leave blank if not.

Link to the actionOptional

A link to the primary source, not to a summary or a thread about it.

Date reviewed

The action itself

0/3 done

Have you read the action itself rather than only a summary of it?

Summaries drop the parts that bind. The on-chain text is what enacts.

NoteOptional

0 words

Do you know the action type and the threshold it has to clear?

The type sets who votes and what counts as passing.

NoteOptional

0 words

Is the scope of what changes stated plainly, without unexplained gaps?

An action that cannot be described in one paragraph cannot be audited later.

NoteOptional

0 words

Evidence

0/3 done

Are the load-bearing claims backed by a source you can open right now?

A claim with no checkable source is an assertion you would be repeating.

NoteOptional

0 words

Can you reproduce the headline numbers from the figures given?

Totals that do not rebuild usually hide either an omission or a double count.

NoteOptional

0 words

Have the proposers answered the questions already put to them in public?

Unanswered public questions are the cheapest available signal.

NoteOptional

0 words

The money

0/3 done

Is the budget broken into units and rates rather than a single total?

A total you cannot decompose is a number you cannot test.

NoteOptional

0 words

Is it clear whether the request is in ADA or fiat, and who carries the price risk?

Silence on denomination moves price risk to the treasury by default.

NoteOptional

0 words

Is any contingency stated as a percentage of a defined base?

Contingency without a base is an unbounded line item.

NoteOptional

0 words

Delivery and conduct

0/3 done

Are payments tied to milestones with acceptance evidence somebody can verify?

Money released against dates rather than artefacts has no failure path.

NoteOptional

0 words

Can you verify the team's delivery record from outside the proposal?

Self-reported track records are the claim, not the evidence.

NoteOptional

0 words

Have you checked this action against your own conflict register?

A conflict found after the vote cannot be disclosed before it.

NoteOptional

0 words

Closing the scan

0/1 done

Your own reading, beyond the arithmetic

The verdict is generated from your answers. This is where you say what it misses.

0 words

Working notesOptional

Anything the structured fields do not cover.

0 words

Scan verdict

Scan incomplete

0/12 answered

12 of 12 checks still unanswered. A verdict on a partial scan would be worth less than no verdict.

Publishable summary

Red Flag Scan of This action: scan incomplete.

No flags raised across the twelve checks.

The scan is not finished, so no verdict has been reached.

This verdict is generated from your own answers. The Institute does not endorse, coordinate or prescribe how any member votes.

The DRep Standards Institute provides decision-support tools. It does not determine how any DRep votes. This record was produced independently by its author.

0% - autosaves in this browser